OUR TEAM | OUR SCOOP | OUR ADVISORS

Blog Watching
Scoop08 scours the daily political blogs to bring you the most important and interesting posts of the day.
Visit the Blog      Join Scoop08      Suggest Stories
Welcome To Your Newsroom SUBMISSIONS POLICY
Column Letter Feature Idea

Scoop08Personalities



Scoop08 Video Contest | Submit


Have an idea or tip? Write us:

Choose Your Beat:
Constitution Party Democrats
Green Party
Independents
Libertarian Party
Reform Party
Republicans
Socialist Party
Write-in Candidates

Arts
Combat & Conflict
Economics
Education
Energy
Environment
Guns & Safety
Healthcare
Immigration
Gender & Sexuality
Poverty
Technology
Terrorism
Women's Issues

Culture
Debates
Democracy
Ethics
Fashion
Generation
Global Policy
Media
Philosophy
Rhetoric
Sports
Spouses & Families
Strategy
Youth Vote

Africa
Asia
Australia
Canada
Europe
Mexico
Middle East
South America
BLOG
PUBLISHED ON: November 28, 2007 - 9:49pm
PUBLISHED IN:

Romney and McCain's Heated Exchange Over Torture

Jennifer Jenkins   Florida Correspondent

Torture is a divisive issue for Republicans; most seek to walk a fine line between national security and human rights. When asked how other candidates have the authority to disagree with McCain, as he is the only candidate who has experienced torture, Romney argued that a presidential candidate should not have to describe what is and isn't torture. He did, however, take a hard stance on the right of enemy combatants: to much applause, he stressed that they should remain at Guantanamo and meet "GIs and CIA interrogators." McCain responded harshly to his statements, pointing out that Romney clearly did not understand waterboarding and condemned anyone who considered it a legitimate, moral interrogation technique: "I suggest you talk to retired military officers. How in the world could anybody think that was fine?" Romney retorted that he understood what it was. McCain pointed out that, if he was not able to define what condones torture, he would have to withdrawal from the Geneva Convention -- a valid point, considering that waterboarding is questionable under the Geneva Convention. Ultimately, it would have been interesting to hear other candidates' responses, seeing as to how Romney and McCain are known to be polar opposites when it comes to controversial interrogation techniques.